-
Lately there's been a lot of flap between Writers and Agents. One of my friends on facebook and Blogger wrote some scathing posts, which received some flaming comments both in agreement and in rebuttal. Well, let me take that back. There has always been tension between writers and agents. This is just the most recent round.
So why can't we all just get along? We all want the same things, right? With all of the “I love my agent” acknowledgments in the back of books, we can assume published authors get along quite nicely with their agents. So the problem is in the struggling writer – busy agent relationship.
One of the dynamics involved is time management and priorities. The number one priority to a writer is honing her/his craft and getting published. Taking precious time away from writing to fine tune a query, a synopsis, and search through a slush pile of agents is annoying. Then being sent a form letter rejection, or no acknowledgment at all, is frustrating to say the least.
Agents number one priority is selling their clients work. A close second, but second none the less, is finding new clients. So an unagented, unpublished, writer starts out on the back burner. That is understandable. If she were your agent, you would not want her to neglect your manuscript spending too much time in the query pile. So, in their spare moments, agents hurriedly dig through queries looking for the next great novelist.
In a perfect world – writers POV – an agent would thoughtfully read your work, and if they chose to pass on it they would offer you wonderfully helpful suggestions on how to improve it. Wouldn't that be grand. That is unlikely from the most basic business POV. Why is agent A going to help you improve your work so that agent B can sell it? If agent A is going to take the time to help you polish a manuscript, agent A should have the opportunity to sell it.
We are back to time and priorities. Agent A is doing all those wonderful things for her clients. That's why they praise her in their books and why she only has time to send you a form letter. Agent A is also getting a little frustrated - when she takes a little time between reading one of her authors latest manuscripts, and talking to an editor about another clients book, to read some queries – that half the queries are not even close to her submission guidelines and many are amateurish at best.
Now I'm not being an agent fan-boy. I can understand their priorities, however. Yet writers have priorities as well. We spend hours searching for potential agents, hours studying their submission guidelines (every one is slightly different), and hours preparing individual submissions for each agent. Then they want us to wait weeks for a reply, and some don't even take the time to reply at all.
Writers really get the feeling that we are not on the back burner, we are out back in the privy. The lack of a response is what angers me. Almost all agents have a standard rejection letter. Many accept email queries. A form response to an email can be sent with a single click. It can even be programmed to be automatic when the busy agent presses delete or moves the file into a special folder. Not sending at least a form rejection is rude, thoughtless, and shows a lack of respect to the writer's hard work.
I will not send a query to an agent that doesn't respond. If they are too busy to click a reply button they are probably too busy to actually read my query. I don't like wasting my time. I'm not even sure those agents even read queries. I think they just keep them coming in - in the event they lose a client or get bored. Again, very disrespectful to the writers who spend precious time preparing the queries.
So agents feel over-worked and under-appreciated by writers, and writers feel that agents are dismissive and disrespectful. It helps if we try to put ourselves in each others shoes for a bit, but even then there are writers and agents who are just not professional. They give us all a bad name and stir the dissension.
What we do need to do is stop generalizing. Every writer and every agent is an individual. Our true quest is to find each other. The agent/author relationship has been referred to as a marriage – not every two people are compatible, but hopefully we can find the one who complements us.
The way I look at it, if an agent I send a query to doesn't jump at the chance to represent my work, she is not the right agent. I don't see rejections as personal attacks on my abilities. They are what they are. That's not arrogance on my part, just realism. When I find the right agent she, or he, will be as excited about my work as I am, and that agent will sell my work with enthusiasm.
max
*Just an aside after I wrote this post: I got a rejection today from a query I sent out in November. That's six months ago. I'm not sure how to read that – a very busy, yet diligent agent; a very thorough, deliberative agent; an agent cleaning out old emails that were never read? At least they responded.